You call your agent to ask whether a small roof leak would be covered. You decide not to file. A year later, a new insurer quotes you a higher premium and mentions “prior losses.” The reason may be sitting in a database you have never looked at: your CLUE report.
A CLUE report is the claims history file insurers check before they write or price a home or auto policy. You can get a free copy, check it for mistakes, and dispute errors. If you are shopping for insurance or buying a house, it is worth ten minutes of your time.
What is a CLUE report?
CLUE stands for Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange. It is a claims information exchange run by LexisNexis that collects and reports up to seven years of auto and personal property claims (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau). LexisNexis is a consumer reporting agency, so the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act gives you rights over the report, much like your credit report.
There are two angles in a home CLUE report: claims you made as a person, and claims tied to the property itself. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that the report lists claims on your home even if you weren’t the owner at the time.
Verisk runs a similar database called A-PLUS. You can get a free copy of each report once a year, CLUE from LexisNexis and A-PLUS from Verisk (Privacy Rights Clearinghouse).
What a CLUE report shows
When you file a claim, insurers can report the date of loss, the loss type and the amount paid, along with the policy number, claim number and insurance company (TDI). A typical home entry looks like this:
| Field | Example |
|---|---|
| Date of loss | 05/14/2024 |
| Loss type | Water damage, wind, hail, theft, liability |
| Status | Closed, paid or closed without payment |
| Amount paid | The total the insurer paid on the claim |
| Insurer, policy and claim numbers | Identify where the record came from |
| Your statement | Optional note you add to explain an entry |
Not every company reports. Claims filed with insurers that don’t subscribe to CLUE won’t appear in the report (Insurify). So a blank report doesn’t always mean a home has no claim history (CNBC Select).
How insurers use your CLUE report
Insurers look at a property’s past claims and use them as a factor in deciding what you pay for homeowners insurance (TDI). Their reasoning is that past claims predict future ones. Certain patterns draw more attention than others:
- Water damage claims, because water problems tend to recur and can mean hidden mold.
- Several claims in a short period, which can lead to a surcharge or a non-renewal.
- Liability claims, such as a dog bite.
- Claims on the house from before you owned it, which can still affect the quote for a buyer.
Can a phone call count as a claim?
Sometimes, yes. This is the part that catches homeowners off guard. The Connecticut Insurance Department explains that calling your company or agent to discuss an actual loss may be treated as reporting a claim, even if no payment is ever made, because the policy requires the insurer to act within set time frames once a loss is reported. A general question about what your policy covers is more likely to be treated as an inquiry.
Many states have since adopted rules limiting whether insurers can count pure inquiries or zero-payment claims against you, but the protections vary. The safe approach:
- When you call to ask a question, say clearly, “I’m not filing a claim. I’m asking a coverage question.”
- Ask general questions (“Does my policy cover a sudden pipe burst?”) before describing a specific loss.
- Get a contractor’s estimate first for small damage. If the repair is close to your deductible, a claim may cost you more in future premiums than it pays.
How to get your free CLUE report
The Fair Credit Reporting Act entitles you to a free copy of your CLUE report (Washington Insurance Commissioner), and you can get one free copy each year from LexisNexis (TDI). To request it:
- Go to the LexisNexis Risk Solutions Consumer Center and request a consumer disclosure report.
- Or call LexisNexis at 866-312-8076 (Bankrate).
- Verify your identity. Have your past addresses and policy numbers handy.
- Review every entry against your own records.
Order your A-PLUS report from Verisk at the same time. It covers similar data and some insurers use it instead.
How to dispute errors on your CLUE report
Common errors include claims that belong to someone else or another property, phone inquiries reported as claims, and losses below the deductible that were never paid (Privacy Rights Clearinghouse). To fix them:
- Dispute with LexisNexis. Under the FCRA, the company must conduct a reasonable investigation of your dispute free of charge (CFPB).
- Contact the insurer that reported it. Ask it to correct the record at the source, in writing.
- Add a statement if the entry is accurate but misleading. You can add an explanation to an item that will show in future reports (Washington Insurance Commissioner). Only consumers can add these notes. Insurers can’t (Utah Insurance Department). For example, if a dog bite claim is on file and you no longer have the dog, say so.
- Ask for a re-quote. Once the report is corrected, ask your insurer or agent to rerun the quote.
Buying a home? Ask for the CLUE report
Only the owner can order the property’s CLUE report, so buyers need to ask the seller for a copy. It can reveal past water damage, roof claims or fire repairs that affect both the home’s condition and what you’ll pay to insure it. Ask for it during your inspection period, and if it shows a major claim, ask the seller for repair invoices and permits.
Sellers can use a clean report as a selling point. Insurify notes that sharing it with buyers can show that a home has had few or no claims in recent years.
Should you file a small claim?
A claim on your CLUE report can follow you for years, so think about the math before filing a small one:
- Compare the repair estimate with your deductible. If the payout would be small, paying yourself may be cheaper over time.
- Ask your agent, in general terms, how claims affect renewal pricing with your company.
- File for real losses that matter. Insurance exists for the big ones, and an unfiled large loss can cost far more than a surcharge.
If you do file, keep the claim well documented from day one. Our guides to the proof of loss form and how long an insurer has to pay a claim can help. For ways to bring premiums down after a claim, see how to lower home insurance.
Frequently asked questions
How long do claims stay on a CLUE report?
CLUE reports generally show up to seven years of auto and personal property claims.
Is a CLUE report free?
Yes. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act you can get a free copy of your CLUE report from LexisNexis once a year, and you may be entitled to another free copy if an insurer takes adverse action based on it.
Does a denied claim show up on a CLUE report?
It can. Reported claims may include those closed without payment. If a denied claim or a simple inquiry appears on your report, you can dispute it or add a statement explaining what happened.
Can a home buyer get the CLUE report?
Only the property owner can order it, so a buyer has to ask the seller for a copy. It is reasonable to request one during the inspection period.
How do I remove an error from my CLUE report?
File a dispute with LexisNexis, which must investigate for free, and ask the insurer that reported the claim to correct it. If the entry is accurate but misleading, add a consumer statement to explain it.
